If I had to eat one sandwich my whole life what would it be? My sister used to make this for my younger brother and I all the time and I loved it. Sometimes she added cheese to it and it elevated it to another level. But I loved it how it was. but you had to use like fluffy bread or it wouldn't turn out as great. She would slice it down the middle and my brother and I would split it. Sometimes she would add some American cheese to it and to this day I could eat it every single day. It serves a nostalgic purpose but also, I freaking love it. Even when it sticks to the roof of your mouth.